Papa's Tomato Pies

Nestled in the heart of Robbinsville Township, New Jersey, Papa's Tomato Pies stands as a beacon for pizza lovers craving an authentic, time-honored experience. This historic pizzeria, with roots tracing back to 1912, brings a rich tradition of classic Italian-American pizza to Main Street, offering a menu that celebrates bold flavors and handcrafted quality.

Step inside, and you're immediately immersed in an inviting, old-school ambiance that perfectly complements the culinary treasures they serve. The warm, nostalgic atmosphere invites guests to savor each bite as if they were partaking in a family legacy passed down through generations.

The true star here is the famed Tomato Pie, revered for its perfectly thin, crisply baked crust that strikes a delicate balance between crunch and tenderness. The sauce is a revelation—rich, vibrant, and boasting just the right level of acidity, made from ripe tomatoes and a secret blend of herbs that ignite your taste buds with every mouthful. For those seeking a twist, the Mustard Pizza with Sausage and Garlic offers an unexpected yet harmonious blend of tangy mustard and savory sausage, delivering layers of depth and complexity.

Other highlights include the Italian Stallion pizza, the airy, creamy White Pizza, and the hearty Pepperoni Pizza, each crafted with precision and passion. Appetizers like the golden, hand-breaded Mozzarella Logs, tangy Bruschetta, and perfectly crisp Jumbo Bone-In Wings are perfect for sharing and set the tone for a meal full of delight.

The menu also tantalizes with hearty sandwiches such as the Grilled Chicken Broccoli Rabe and Provolone wrap and classic Chicken Parm, alongside comforting soups like Chicken Pastina that provide warmth and flavor. Don’t miss out on their decadent desserts—rich Tiramisu, indulgent Large Cannoli, and a luscious Birthday Cake that promises a sweet finish.

Guests rave about the experience: Michelle praises the perfectly thin and crisp crust combined with the exceptional tomato sauce, calling it a “completely changed” pizza experience. Brendan highlights the old-school charm and superb crust, emphasizing the "garlic & oil on the pie" that adds an unforgettable flavor dimension. Brian recalls the dedication to quality seen in the kitchen, where the tomato pie is treated “as important as a newborn child,” a testament to the artisanal care behind every pie.

Mike goes as far as calling it the best pizza on his East Coast trip, boldly stating it “killed New Haven” pizza in his book. Such authentic enthusiasm echoes throughout the community, reinforcing Papa’s Tomato Pies as not just a meal, but a memorable encounter with tradition, passion, and spectacular pizza craftsmanship.

If you find yourself in Robbinsville Township, a visit to Papa’s Tomato Pies isn’t just recommended—it’s essential. Savour their expertly crafted pies, relish their warm hospitality, and discover why this enduring pizzeria has secured its legendary status over a century of unwavering dedication to flavor and quality.

Location: 19 Main St, Robbinsville Twp, NJ 08691, United States
Phone: +1 609-208-0006