Papa's Tomato Pies Menu

Papa’s Tomato Pies, nestled in Robbinsville Township, NJ, is a beacon for pizza lovers seeking authentic Trenton-style tomato pies. Their menu is a blend of tradition and creativity, boasting iconic dishes like the classic Large 16" Plain Tomato Pie, prized for its perfectly thin, crisp crust and balanced tangy sauce. The distinctive Mustard Pie, layered with a thin spread of spicy brown mustard beneath the cheese and sauce, offers a unique local twist that elevates the flavor experience. Beyond pies, Papa’s delights with Italian Stallion, wings, and fresh salads such as Caesar and Caprese, pairing well with their range of dipping sauces—from Garlic Parm Aioli to Boom Boom Sauce. For pasta enthusiasts, entrées like Chicken Cacciatore and Chicken Marsala serve hearty, rich flavors. Desserts like Tiramisu and Large Cannoli round out the meal beautifully. The dedication to quality and tradition shines through every bite, making Papa’s not just a restaurant, but a cherished culinary landmark.